NFL· 5 min read

2026 NFL Redraft After Week 10: Reese Holds Off Bailey at No. 1

Arvell Reese leads David Bailey by half a point, Miami owns three top-10 slots and Fernando Mendoza's first start is in. The 2026 NFL redraft after Week 10.

Arvell Reese is still the first pick if the 2026 NFL draft started over today, but the cushion is down to half a point. Reese scores 92.0 on the live 2026 NFL redraft, David Bailey 91.5. After Week 8 the gap was 1.7.

The bigger story sits one tier down. Miami, a 1-8 team, now has three rookies in the top 10. The board runs through Week 10, with performance carrying 80% of the score and draft slot the other 20%.

The top 10 after Week 10

Change is versus last week's board.

Redraft score, top six
Arvell Reese+92
David Bailey+91.5
Sonny Styles+89.1
Caleb Downs+84
Jacob Rodriguez+82.1
Chris Johnson+81.8

Nine of the 10 are defenders. The tenth is there by our choice, not the formula's.

Why Bailey hasn't caught Reese

Reese doesn't come off the field: 99.5% of the Giants' defensive snaps, 80 tackles, 4.5 sacks, 8 TFL and an interception in nine games. Bailey has the louder pass-rush line, with 7.5 sacks, 10 TFL and five forced fumbles, but on 73.1% of the snaps.

Week 10 was Bailey's quietest game. He had one tackle and two pass breakups in the 31-12 loss to Buffalo, and right tackle Spencer Brown held him without a pressure on 13 one-on-one rushes, per Next Gen Stats via ClutchPoints. The Jets still note his 17 havoc plays, the most by any rookie through 10 weeks since 2019.

Our view: Bailey is the better per-snap player, and Reese is the better rookie season. Snap share is a real skill for a 21-year-old linebacker, and it's why the formula keeps Reese on top. One more multi-sack Bailey game could flip it.

Miami's three-man rookie core

The Dolphins lost 24-22 in Indianapolis, and their rookies were the reason it was close. Chris Johnson, Rodriguez and Taaffe all played 100% of the defensive snaps, per Dolphins Wire.

  • Chris Johnson (No. 6): a tipped-ball interception returned 59 yards for a touchdown, plus a tackle for loss on Jonathan Taylor at the 1, per the Palm Beach Post. Season: 45 tackles, 2 INT, 4 PD, 1 TD on 98.5% of the snaps.
  • Michael Taaffe (No. 10): six tackles and his third interception. The Dolphins say he's their first safety with three picks in a season since 2018. He went 158th; he'd go 148 picks earlier today.
  • Jacob Rodriguez (No. 5): one tackle, his quietest game of the year. He still has 79 tackles on 99.8% of the snaps.

Between them: six interceptions and three forced fumbles, with two of the three taken after the first round.

Mendoza's first start, and why he's at No. 7

Fernando Mendoza got his first start against the defending champions and lost 21-13. He went 17 of 29 for 143 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions, ran six times for 22 yards and a 10-yard score on the opening drive, and was sacked six times, per NFL.com. Ten of his completions came on the first three drives. After that, the Raiders punted on seven straight possessions.

To be clear about the board: Mendoza is a staff placement at No. 7. His formula score is 66.0, which would put him around 26th. Two games and 10.6% of the Raiders' snaps can't tell us much, and quarterbacks gain value late: the 2024 board, measured on career value, has quarterbacks in all four of its top slots. The hold comes off once he has enough starts to judge.

The offense is coming, slowly

The best offensive rookies by formula sit just outside the top 10:

  • 11. Carnell Tate, WR, TEN (pick 4): 34 catches, 413 yards in seven games. He missed a second straight game with a shoulder injury, and Robert Saleh is hopeful he plays at Dallas in Week 11, per RotoWire.
  • 12. Denzel Boston, WR, CLE (pick 39): 33 catches, 523 yards, 3 TD. He played through his toe injury in Week 10 but caught one ball for 16 yards.
  • 16. Spencer Fano, OT, CLE (pick 9), and 19. Francis Mauigoa, OT, NYG (pick 10): neither has missed a snap.

History says don't read too much into the defensive lean. Our live redrafts of past classes, measured on career value, are offense-heavy: the 2023 board has Puka Nacua, a fifth-rounder, at No. 2. Defenders who play every snap fill a box score fast. Receivers and quarterbacks take longer, and pay off longer.

Dynasty notes: one buy, one hold

Buy Jordyn Tyson. The No. 8 pick sits 81st on the board because he spent eight weeks on injured reserve with a hamstring injury. In his second game he caught 11 of a game-high 13 targets for 80 yards against Carolina, playing 45 snaps after 18 in his debut, per nola.com. Most of it was short stuff, but the ranking reflects missed games, not his play.

Hold Anthony Hill. Tennessee's linebacker slid five spots to No. 13 after missing Week 10 with a neck injury. He still leads all rookies with 82 tackles, in eight games. One missed week isn't a reason to sell.

What to watch in Week 11

Mendoza's second start is at Denver, Tate's shoulder decides whether Tennessee gets its best receiver back, and Miami's three rookies go to Buffalo. Bailey gets the Chargers. The board refreshes after Monday night's game.

Keep going

Watch it move live

The 2026 NFL redraft re-sorts every morning with the latest games.

Live 2026 NFL redraft →2026 NFL rookie stats →Rookies by team →Position rankings →
Piggyhop logo
Sponsored
Piggyhop: the AI money app
Track your money with Piggyhop.
Get the app

Published Nov 17, 2026. Numbers reflect the board on the publish date; the live board keeps moving. How the redrafts work · Editorial standards & corrections.

Related articles

All →